The timing of retirement can often have substantial consequences.
Two retirees can:
- Start with the same amount
- Invest in the same portfolio
- Withdraw the same amount
- Receive the same annual returns
Yet, they can finish with dramatically different balances.
This is called sequence of returns risk.
One retiree can finish with nearly twice as much money as the other.
The only difference? The order in which those returns arrive.
Meet Margaret and Diane
They are sisters, born two years apart. They grew up in the same house, attended the same schools and spent most of their adult lives comparing notes.
Who had the tougher teacher?
Whose children slept through the night first?
Who makes a better chicken salad?
That question remains unresolved and occasionally threatens the family summer vacation.
They also followed similar financial paths. Both worked for more than 35 years. Both saved consistently. Both retired at age 65 with $1 million invested. Each sister planned to withdraw $50,000 from her portfolio at the end of every year. They even invested in portfolios that earned the same annual returns over the following 10 years.
You could reasonably assume they would end up in the same place.
They did not.
Margaret retires into a bad market
Margaret retires first and almost immediately, markets begin to tumble.
Her first three annual returns are:
- − 20%
- − 15%
- − 10%
Not exactly the retirement gift she had hoped for.
During those same years, Margaret still needs money to live. The electric company does not accept "the market is down" as a reason to skip a bill. She takes her planned $50,000 withdrawal each year while her portfolio is declining.
After the first year, her $1 million portfolio falls to ~ $750,000
After the second year, it falls to ~ $587,500
After the third year, it is down to ~ $478,750
The market eventually improves and over the remaining seven years Margaret receives returns of the following:
- 5%
- 8%
- 10%
- 12%
- 15%
- 18%
- 20%
Those are excellent returns.
Unfortunately, the recovery is now working on a much smaller portfolio. At the end of the 10 years, after taking $500,000 of withdrawals, Margaret has approximately $527,000 remaining. Margaret didn't make an investing mistake. She simply had bad timing.
Diane gets the good years first
Imagine her sister Diane retires into the mirror image.
She also begins with $1 million and withdraws $50,000 at the end of each year.
Her portfolio earns the exact same annual returns as Margaret's, with one exception.
She receives those returns in reverse order.
Her first three years returns are:
- 20%
- 18%
- 15%
After the first year, Diane has approximately $1.15 million, even after taking her $50,000 withdrawal.
After the second year, she has ~ $1.31 million.
After the third year, she has ~ $1.45 million.
The difficult years eventually arrive.
Diane experiences the same −10%, −15% and −20% returns that Margaret did. These returns arrive near the end of the decade, after Diane's portfolio has already grown substantially. At the end of the same 10 years, after taking the same $500,000 of withdrawals, Diane has approximately $983,000 remaining.
The sisters started with the same amount.
They withdrew the same amount.
Over the course of a decade they received the same annual returns.
Margaret finished with ~ $527,000.
Diane finished with ~ $983,000.
The order of the returns created a difference of ~ $456,000.
The returns used in this example are hypothetical and intentionally simplified. Investment expenses, taxes and inflation are not included. The purpose is to isolate the order in which investment returns occur.
Wait, didn't they earn the same average return?
Yes.
The sisters experienced the same list of returns. If neither sister had taken withdrawals, the order would not change the ending results.
Same returns and same ending balance. With no withdrawals, both sisters end with roughly $1.4 Million in their portfolios.
Unfortunately, retirement adds another ingredient.
Withdrawals.
Once money is leaving the portfolio, the order matters. Margaret was removing money while her account was already shrinking. That left fewer dollars invested when the strong returns finally had arrived.
Diane received strong returns while more of her original money was invested. Her portfolio built a cushion before the difficult years began.
Before retirement, market declines are different
While you were working, a market decline is unpleasant, but usually manageable.
You still have employment income. You may continue contributing to your retirement accounts. Those contributions purchase more shares at lower prices. Time and continued savings can work in your favor.
Retirement changes that equation.
Instead of adding money, you begin removing it. A declining market combined with withdrawals can force you to sell more shares to generate the same amount of cash.
Suppose an investment is worth $100 per share.
To create $50,000 of spending money you would need to sell 500 shares.
If the investment falls to $80 per share, you now need to sell 625 shares to generate the same amount.
Those additional 125 shares are no longer invested when the market eventually recovers. You cannot spend a share and keep it invested at the same time. This is why volatility may be temporary on a market chart but can have a permanent impact on a portfolio.
The first few years matter most
Sequence of returns risk is generally the most dangerous near the beginning of retirement.
A bad year at age 85 may still be uncomfortable, but by then, the portfolio has already supported decades of withdrawals and the remaining planning period could be shorter.
A major market decline at age 66 can affect every year that follows. The portfolio has less time to recover and the retiree may need to continue withdrawing from it for another 25 to 30 years.
This does not mean every person who retires before a bear market will run out of money. It means the early years deserve more attention than a simple average return assumption might suggest.
We have all seen them. Retirement projections showing a smooth 6–8% return every year. That illustration can be useful. The market, however, has not been known for its commitment to smoothness.
The answer is not to avoid stocks
Sequence of returns risk can lead retirees towards the wrong conclusion. They may believe the safest solution is to sell all of their stocks and keep everything in cash or short term bonds.
That eliminates one risk by introducing others.
A retirement may last 25 or 30 years. Over that period, inflation can steadily reduce purchasing power. A portfolio generally needs some opportunity for growth to support rising expenses and a long retirement.
The purpose of investing in retirement is not to eliminate every fluctuation. That is nearly impossible. The goal is to avoid being forced to sell too much of a declining asset at the wrong time. That requires more than picking a stock to bond asset allocation.
It requires a withdrawal strategy.
How near retirees can prepare
No strategy can guarantee that a portfolio will survive every possible market outcome, but there are ways to reduce the damage that poor market returns early in retirement can cause.
Keep short term spending needs outside of the stock market
Money expected to be spent soon generally should not depend entirely on next month stock prices. A retiree might hold a portion of upcoming withdrawals in cash, money market funds, short term bonds or other relatively stable investments.
The appropriate amount depends on the household. Some retirees may hold one year of planned portfolio withdrawals in cash. Others may hold several years across cash and high quality bonds. The purpose is not to predict a market decline. It is to create another source of spending if one occurs.
If stocks, fall sharply, the retiree may be able to use the more stable portion of the portfolio rather than selling the stocks immediately.
Rebalance instead of selling everything proportionally
Imagine a portfolio that begins at 60% stocks and 40% bonds.
Stocks decline, while bonds hold their value or decline less.
The portfolio may now be closer to 50% stocks and 50% bonds.
A retiree who needs cash could potentially take the withdrawal from the bond side while also moving the portfolio closer to its intended allocation. Instead of automatically selling stocks after they fall, the retirees sells from the portion of the portfolio that has held up better.
Rebalancing is not a magic shield. Bonds can still lose value too, but a diversified portfolio creates more choices than a portfolio invested entirely in one asset class.
Make discretionary spending flexible
Not every retirement expense has the same priority.
Property taxes, groceries and insurance premiums generally need to be paid. A major vacation, new car or home renovation may have more flexibility. Reducing discretionary withdrawals temporarily after a severe market decline can give the portfolio more room to recover.
This does not necessarily mean canceling retirement. It may mean, postponing the kitchen renovation for a year or taking a less expensive trip.
A small adjustment during a difficult market can be more effective than waiting until the portfolio is under serious pressure and making a much larger adjustment later.
Coordinate withdrawals with reliable income
Social Security and pensions can cover part of retirees essential expenses without requiring an investment sale. The more basic spending that is covered by reliable income, the less the portfolio may need to provide during the market downturn.
This does not mean everyone should delay Social Security . The timing of reliable income and portfolio withdrawals should be evaluated together. Withdrawals should be evaluated together. An investment portfolio should not be asked to perform a job that another income source is already equipped to handle.
Avoid unnecessary risk
A person who accumulated wealth with an aggressive portfolio may assume the same strategy should continue unchanged after retirement but in reality, the purpose of the portfolio has changed.
During the working years, the primary goal may have been growth. In retirement, the portfolio may need to provide growth, income, stability and liquidity all at the same time.
That does not always require a dramatic change. It does require an intentional review.
Someone who needs regular withdrawals from a portfolio invested almost entirely in stocks may be especially exposed if a severe decline occur shortly after retired. The right allocation depends on spending needs, reliable income, tax situation, time horizon, risk tolerance/capacity and the amount of flexibility built into the plan.
There is no single retirement portfolio for everyone.
“What if the market crash is right after I retire?”
After sitting across the table from hundreds of households, this is one of the most common fears.
It is a reasonable concern. No one knows what the market will do during a particular retirement year. Waiting for everything to feel safe is unlikely to solve the problem.
Markets do not send an invitation, announcing that the ideal retirement date has arrived.
Options matter most when markets are not cooperating.
As for Margaret and Diane
Margaret is not necessarily doomed. The 10 year example shows the damage that can occur when poor returns arrive early and withdrawals continue without adjustment. A real financial plan would not simply watch the account decline for three years and hope for better weather.
Margaret might have used cash for part of her spending. She might've withdrawn from bonds instead of stocks. She could've postponed a large discretionary purchase. She may have had Social Security or pension income covering much of her basic spending.
The point is not that Diane made better investment selections. As a matter of fact, she did not. The point is that Margaret's plan needed to withstand a more difficult order of events.
The sisters could control how much they saved.
They could control how they invested.
They could control how much they withdrew.
The sisters cannot control market returns.
Margaret and Diane received the same investment returns. They simply received them in a different order. Sometimes, the sequence of those returns changes everything.
Any client specific information in this article, including names, ages, family, relationships, financial figures and investment results, is fictionalized and used for illustrative purposes only. The hypothetical examples do not represent the performance of any particular investment or portfolio. They exclude taxes, investment expenses and inflation and they are not intended to predict future results.