Medicare & Social Security

The Medicare Cliff Most Retirees Never See Coming

How $1 of extra income can cost a retired couple nearly $2,300, two years later.

The Medicare Cliff Most Retirees Never See Coming

A few months ago, I wrote Medicare 101 , a simple guide to Parts A, B, C, D and Medigap.

Buried inside that article was one sentence:

If your income is above certain thresholds, you pay a surcharge on top of your normal Medicare premiums.

I promised to explain that surcharge in the future and this is that issue.

The surcharge is called IRMAA, which stands for Income Related Monthly Adjustment Amount.

It sounds like either a government agency or a tropical storm.

Unfortunately, it can do some damage either way.

The letter that arrived two years later

Let’s call them Bill and Susan.

Bill is 70. Susan is 68. Both are retired and enrolled in Medicare.

They did many things right.

They saved consistently. They waited to claim Social Security. They built a healthy retirement portfolio and had money spread across Traditional IRAs, Roth IRAs and a taxable brokerage account.

In 2024, they completed a Roth conversion.

The idea was simple.

Move some money from their Traditional IRA into a Roth IRA now, pay the tax today and reduce the amount that could be taxed later.

The conversion was not enormous. It did not push them into the highest tax bracket. It did not cause an obvious tax emergency.

They filed their return, paid the tax and moved on with their lives.

Then, near the end of 2025, a letter arrived from Social Security.

Their Medicare premiums were going up in 2026.

Bill called me with the letter sitting on the kitchen counter.

“I thought Medicare was supposed to cost $202.90 per month,” he said. “Why are they charging us more?”

The answer was sitting on a tax return from two years earlier.

Their 2024 modified adjusted gross income, or MAGI, was $218,480.

The 2026 IRMAA threshold for a married couple filing jointly was $218,000.

They were $480 over the line.

That $480 did not create an extra $480 Medicare bill.

It created an additional $2,296.80 in annual Medicare premiums for the couple.

That is not a typo.

How $480 became nearly $2,300

For 2026, the standard Medicare Part B premium is $202.90 per person per month.

A married couple with 2024 MAGI of $218,000 or less pays the standard premium.

But once joint MAGI rises above $218,000, the first IRMAA tier begins.

Each spouse pays:

  • An additional $81.20 per month for Medicare Part B
  • An additional $14.50 per month for Medicare Part D

That is an extra $95.70 per person per month.

For Bill and Susan:

  • $95.70 per person
  • Times two people
  • Times 12 months
  • Total additional cost: $2,296.80

The income threshold applies to their joint tax return.

The surcharge applies separately to each spouse enrolled in Medicare.

One line on the tax return can therefore create two monthly surcharges.

The Medicare Cliff Most Retirees Never See Coming

The $1 cliff

Most federal income tax brackets work like ramps.

When you cross into a higher tax bracket, only the dollars above that line are taxed at the higher rate.

IRMAA works more like a staircase.

You do not gradually slide into the next level.

You step onto it.

For a married couple in 2026:

  • MAGI of $218,000 means no IRMAA surcharge.
  • MAGI of $218,001 means the first IRMAA surcharge applies.

That additional dollar of income could theoretically cost a couple with both spouses on Medicare nearly $2,300 over the year.

The government does not send you a tiny surcharge for going slightly over.

It sends you the whole step.

There are additional IRMAA tiers at higher income levels, with progressively larger Part B and Part D surcharges. But the first tier is often the most surprising because households can cross it through fairly ordinary retirement decisions.

Why the bill arrives two years late

IRMAA has an unusual delay built into it.

Social Security generally uses income from two years earlier to determine your current Medicare premiums.

That means:

  • Your 2024 income generally determines your 2026 Medicare premiums.
  • Your 2025 income will generally determine your 2027 Medicare premiums.
  • Your 2026 income will generally determine your 2028 Medicare premiums.

This delay is what makes the surcharge feel like it appeared out of nowhere.

You sell an investment, complete a Roth conversion or take a large IRA withdrawal.

You pay the tax.

The calendar changes.

You forget about it.

Then Social Security sends you a letter two years later, like a waiter bringing the bill long after you have left the restaurant.

The number Medicare actually uses

IRMAA is based on modified adjusted gross income or MAGI.

For this purpose, Medicare generally calculates MAGI as:

MAGI = AGI (line 11 of Form 1040) + Tax Exempt Interest (line 2a of Form 1040)

This creates two common surprises.

Surprise No. 1: The standard deduction does not protect you

A couple may have a large standard deduction that reduces their taxable income.

That can help with their federal income tax bill.

But the standard deduction is applied after adjusted gross income is calculated. It does not reduce the MAGI Medicare uses for IRMAA.

The tax return may say you owe little federal income tax.

Medicare may still see plenty of income.

Surprise No. 2: Tax exempt interest still counts

Municipal bond interest may be exempt from federal income tax.

It is not invisible to Medicare.

Social Security adds tax exempt interest back when calculating MAGI for IRMAA.

The IRS may call it tax exempt. Medicare still wants it on the guest list.

What can push someone over the line?

IRMAA is rarely caused by one mysterious Medicare transaction.

It is usually caused by income stacking together on a tax return.

Common examples include:

  • Roth conversions
  • Traditional IRA withdrawals
  • Required minimum distributions
  • Pension income
  • The taxable portion of Social Security
  • Interest and dividends
  • Realized capital gains
  • Capital gain distributions from mutual funds
  • Tax exempt municipal bond interest
  • The sale of a business, property or concentrated stock position

A Roth conversion is especially important because the previously untaxed portion converted from a Traditional IRA generally becomes taxable income in the year of conversion.

That does not make Roth conversions bad.

It simply means the conversion needs to be evaluated alongside the rest of the tax return, not in isolation.

Was Bill and Susan’s Roth conversion a mistake?

Not necessarily.

This is where retirement planning requires more nuance than “IRMAA is bad.”

Suppose the conversion helps Bill and Susan:

  • Reduce future required minimum distributions
  • Avoid a higher tax bracket later
  • Build more tax free Roth assets
  • Leave more flexible assets to their children
  • Reduce the taxable income of a surviving spouse in the future

Those long term benefits could easily be worth more than a one year $2,297 Medicare surcharge.

The goal is not to avoid IRMAA at all costs.

That would be like refusing to earn an extra $20,000 because you do not want to pay tax on it.

The real question is:

Does the long term benefit of the decision outweigh the additional tax and Medicare cost?

Sometimes the answer will be no.

Sometimes the answer will be yes.

But the surcharge should be part of the calculation before the transaction happens, not discovered when the letter arrives.

Medicare is a cost to consider.

It is not always a reason to abandon an otherwise good strategy.

Why leaving a cushion matters

Future IRMAA thresholds are not always known when you are making the income decision.

The 2027 thresholds, for example, may not yet be available when someone is planning a Roth conversion earlier in 2025.

That means the calculation sometimes requires an estimate.

It also means aiming to land exactly one dollar below a projected threshold is not much of a plan.

Other income can move during the year.

Dividends may be higher than expected. A mutual fund may distribute a capital gain. Bank interest may increase. A tax form may arrive with a number you did not anticipate.

When planning around an IRMAA threshold, it is generally wise to leave some breathing room.

Parking exactly at the edge of the cliff is still parking at the edge of the cliff.

Can you appeal IRMAA?

Sometimes.

There are two broad situations to consider.

First, Social Security may have used incorrect or outdated information. Perhaps your tax return was amended, your filing status is wrong or the income information does not match your records. In that case, you may be able to challenge the decision.

Second, your income may have fallen because of a qualifying “life changing” event.

Social Security lists events such as:

  • Marriage
  • Divorce or annulment
  • Death of a spouse
  • Stopping work
  • Reducing work hours
  • Certain losses of income producing property
  • Loss of pension income
  • Certain employer settlement payments

Someone who recently retired may receive an IRMAA notice based on the salary they earned two years earlier.

That person may be able to ask Social Security to use a more recent estimate of income by filing Form SSA-44 and providing supporting documentation.

This can make an enormous difference.

However, voluntarily completing a Roth conversion, selling appreciated stock or taking a large IRA withdrawal is not, by itself, among the listed “life changing” events.

“I did not realize this would increase my Medicare premiums” is understandable.

It is generally not the type of life changing event the form is designed to address.

What I would review before creating income

Before completing a large Roth conversion, realizing a capital gain or taking an optional IRA distribution, I would want to answer five questions.

1. What is your projected MAGI?

Not taxable income.

Not just the amount of the proposed transaction.

The entire projected adjusted gross income, plus tax exempt interest.

2. Which tax year will affect Medicare?

A transaction today may affect premiums two years from now.

That future Medicare cost should be included in the analysis.

3. How close are you to the next threshold?

Being $30,000 below a threshold is different from being $300 below it.

4. Can the transaction be spread across multiple years?

One $80,000 conversion may produce a different result than two $40,000 conversions.

The same can be true for capital gains or discretionary IRA withdrawals.

5. Is crossing the threshold still worth it?

Sometimes paying IRMAA is the correct decision.

The important thing is to cross the threshold knowingly because the strategy produces a larger benefit elsewhere.

That is very different from crossing it accidentally.

As for Bill and Susan

Their conversion still made sense.

The additional Medicare cost was frustrating but it did not erase the value of moving money into their Roth accounts.

What changed was how we approached the following year.

We projected their income earlier.

We monitored interest, dividends and capital gains.

We left more room below the estimated threshold.

And we evaluated the Roth conversion based on the total cost, including federal tax, state tax and future Medicare premiums.

There was no magic strategy.

Just a more complete calculation.

Takeaway

IRMAA is not a reason to panic. It is a reason to coordinate.

A retirement income decision can affect more than this year’s tax return. It can also affect Medicare premiums two years later.

The most important lessons are simple:

  • Medicare uses MAGI, not taxable income.
  • Tax exempt interest still counts.
  • The calculation generally looks back two years.
  • The surcharge applies in tiers rather than gradually.
  • A married couple can face two surcharges from one joint income threshold.
  • A Roth conversion can still be worthwhile, even if it triggers IRMAA.
  • Retirement and certain other life events may allow you to request a lower surcharge.

You do not need to memorize every threshold.

You just need to know when you are approaching one.

Because sometimes one extra dollar of income is not really one extra dollar.

Sometimes it comes with a $2,300 receipt attached.


Any client specific information in this article, including but not limited to names, ages, locations, family details, occupations and financial figures, is fictionalized for privacy purposes and used for illustrative examples only.


Sources

All articles

Let’s connect

A 30-minute conversation to see whether we’re a fit. No planning on the call, no pressure, and you’ll leave knowing something you didn’t before.