Inflation doesn’t announce itself.
It doesn’t crash the market on a Tuesday morning or make the news crawl on CNBC. It just quietly shows up every year and takes a little something off the top of your purchasing power, like a house guest who keeps helping themselves to your leftovers without ever technically asking.
Most people don’t notice it until they do and then they can’t stop thinking about it.
Every time I go out for coffee, I do the same thing.
I order, I tap my card and I spend just a little longer than I should staring at the receipt. Not because I can’t afford it. Just because I remember when a cup of coffee didn’t require a brief moment of silent acceptance before moving on with my day.
That’s inflation. If it’s hitting you at the coffee counter, it’s worth asking what it’s quietly doing to your portfolio over time.
First, what is inflation?
Inflation is simply the rate at which prices rise over time.
Here’s a concrete way to think about it. In 1916, nine cents would buy a quart of milk. By 1966, nine cents would only get you a small glass. By 2017, nine cents would buy about seven tablespoons. The money is the same. What it buys is not.
That gap between what your dollars are worth today and what they’ll be worth in the future is the real enemy of retirement planning. Not market crashes. Not bad years. The slow, quiet erosion of purchasing power over 20 or 30 years.
The Federal Reserve aims for roughly 2% annual inflation. That level is considered healthy. Prices rising slowly is a sign of a growing economy. The problem comes when inflation runs hotter than that or when it becomes unpredictable.
So what does inflation actually do to stocks?
This is where most people expect a simple answer. Higher inflation, lower stocks. But the data is more nuanced than that.
Dimensional Fund Advisors looked at the last 30 years of S&P 500 returns alongside inflation data.
Their conclusion: there is no reliable year-to-year connection between high inflation and poor stock returns.
In fact, 23 of the 30 years from 1996 through 2025 saw positive stock returns even after adjusting for inflation. Over that entire stretch, the S&P 500 returned 7.6% per year after inflation.
2021 is a good example. Inflation was rising fast that year. Stocks still had a strong year. Then in 2022, stocks had a rough year with similar inflation. The two don’t move together as cleanly as people assume.
Zoom out further and the picture gets even more reassuring. One dollar invested in the S&P 500 in 1926 would have grown to more than $500 in real purchasing power by the end of 2017. One dollar left in Treasury bills over that same period? It grew to $1.51.
Stocks, for all their short-term noise, have been one of the most reliable tools humans have ever invented for staying ahead of rising prices over the long run.
But here’s where it gets complicated.
That long run story is real and it comes with a caveat.
There have been meaningful stretches where stocks failed to outpace inflation, sometimes for years at a time.
From 1966 to 1982, the S&P 500 returned 6.8% per year before inflation. After accounting for inflation, that return dropped to exactly 0%.
Sixteen years of investing, flat in real terms.
From 2000 to 2009, the so-called “lost decade”, the S&P 500 returned -0.9% before inflation. After adjusting, it was -3.4%.
Fighting inflation in retirement
For a 35-year-old, a prolonged rough patch with inflation is uncomfortable. It is not catastrophic. They are not drawing down yet. They have time.
For someone in their 60s or 70s, the math shifts.
If you are taking withdrawals from your portfolio every year, and inflation is running hot at the same time, you face what planners call a double squeeze. Your withdrawals are buying less in the real world, so you may need to pull out more dollars to cover the same expenses. And if the market is flat or down during that same stretch, you are selling more shares at lower prices to cover those withdrawals.
High inflation early in retirement is especially dangerous. A bad stretch in your first five or ten years of drawing down can permanently reduce how long your money lasts, even if the market recovers strongly afterward.
What actually helps
A few things are worth examining if inflation stays elevated.
Check whether your income sources adjust with inflation. Social Security does, through its annual cost of living adjustment. Most pensions do not. A fixed pension check of $3,000 per month today will buy meaningfully less in 15 years if inflation averages even 3%.
Think about staying invested in equities. The long run case for stocks as an inflation fighter is strong, even though short stretches can be painful. Retirees who hold too little in equities out of fear are sometimes trading one risk for another.
Treasury Inflation Protected Securities, or TIPS, are another option worth knowing about. They are government bonds that adjust in value as inflation rises. They may not offer the growth potential of stocks, but they are specifically designed to protect purchasing power.
And think about withdrawal flexibility. If you can pull back slightly on spending during high-inflation stretches, even modestly, you protect more of your principal and give your portfolio room to recover.
None of this requires dramatic action. It requires awareness and a plan that accounts for the reality that inflation does not always go back to 2% on schedule.
If any of this raised a question about your own situation, just hit reply and send it my way. These are exactly the conversations I have with clients every day and I’m glad to work through the numbers with you.
Sources
- Dimensional Fund Advisors, “Will Inflation Hurt Stock Returns? Not Necessarily.” - https://www.dimensional.com -- Used in this article to explain: the lack of a reliable year-to-year connection between inflation and stock returns, the 23 out of 30 positive-return years, and the 7.6% annualized real return figure.
- OneBridge Wealth Management, “A Brief History of Inflation and the Stock Market” -- https://www.onebridgewealth.com/blog/a-brief-history-of-inflation-and-the-stock-market -- Used in this article to explain: the long-run correlation between elevated inflation and compressed real returns, and the observation that best real returns occur during moderate inflation environments.
- WealthGen Advisors, “Navigating Stagflation: Lessons from the 1970s and Today” -- https://wealthgenadvisor.com/navigating-stagflation-lessons-from-the-1970s-and-today/ -- Used in this article to explain: the real return data from 1973-1982 and how equities lost purchasing power during prolonged high-inflation periods.
- Kitces.com, “How Sequence-Of-Inflation Risk Impacts Retirees” -- https://www.kitces.com/blog/sequence-of-inflation-risk-retirement-investment-monte-carlo-technology/ -- Used in this article to explain: why high inflation early in retirement is especially damaging and can permanently reduce how long a portfolio lasts.
- Kiplinger, “How Inflation Is Impacting Retirees” -- https://www.kiplinger.com/retirement/social-security/how-inflation-is-impacting-retirees -- Used in this article to explain: Social Security COLA as an inflation hedge, strategies for managing inflation risk, and survey data on retiree concerns.