Paul did not intend to put nearly half of his retirement savings into a single stock. There was no big bet. There was no hot tip from a neighbor, nor was there a single moment where he pushed all his chips across the table.
He started with his company in his early 30s and he stayed there for his entire career. Over the years, he received company stock as compensation, bought more stock through the employee stock purchase plan and reinvested dividends along the way.
The company did well and so did Paul.
By the time he retired, he had built a portfolio worth more than $2 million. About $900,000 of his portfolio was invested in his former employer’s stock.
He had only put in about $180,000 over the course of his career, but the stock had been very good to Paul.
When I first met Paul, we talked about reducing it and he asked two questions I would expect just about anybody to ask.
“Why would I sell the best investment I own?” and “Do you know how much tax I'm going to owe?”
Both are fair questions and both are reasons Paul needed a plan.
A great investment can become too important
Selling all $900,000 tomorrow would solve the concentration problem, but Paul was sitting on about $720,000 of unrealized gains.
Long-term capital gains can be taxed federally at 0%, 15% or 20%, depending on taxable income. Some higher-income taxpayers can also face a 3.8% net investment income tax. State taxes can add another layer.
A giant sale would come with a giant bill, and understandably, Paul was not too excited about it.
Paul needed an exit ramp.
Start with the destination
Before selling a single share, I wanted Paul to decide what he was working toward. Did he want to get out completely? Did he want to hold onto some shares? How much of his retirement income actually depends on this one position?
The right number will be different for every investor. Someone with a large pension and plenty of money beyond what they will ever spend can tolerate more concentration in a single stock than someone relying heavily on a portfolio for retirement income.
Selling some shares when the timing feels right is not a plan. Paul needed a target and a rough timetable for getting to his destination.
Fortunately he had options.
Spread the sale across several tax years
Paul's $720,000 gain does not have to appear on a single year's tax return. He can sell shares of his position over several years. Retirement could give him that opportunity.
Let’s say Paul retires at 65 and his paychecks disappear. Perhaps he delays Social Security and his required minimum distributions are still several years away.
These lower income years could be a window of opportunity to realize capital gains at a far more favorable tax cost.
Harvest losses elsewhere
Paul's company stock is not the only investment in his portfolio. Suppose we sell some shares and realize a gain of $60,000. Other areas of his portfolio happen to have a loss of about $20,000.
Capital losses generally offset capital gains. If losses exceed gains, individuals can generally deduct up to $3,000 of additional net capital losses against other income for the year and carry any remaining losses forward to future years.
Nobody likes to see an investment fall, but if the loss already exists, it may be useful to Paul as he tries to diversify a highly appreciated position.
Charity can help shrink the position too
Suppose Paul gives $20,000 to his favorite charity every year.
In previous years he wrote a check, while sitting on a stock he would not sell because he was concerned about the tax bill.
Selling shares and donating the cash means passing through a tollbooth. The capital gains tax comes out first.
Donating the shares goes around that tollbooth. Paul paid about $.20 on the dollar for that stock, so a $20,000 gift carries about $16,000 of gains that he never has to report.
If he itemizes, he can generally deduct today's value too, though new limits this year trim that a bit.
Only giving above 0.5% of your income counts and stock gifts are capped at 30% of your income for the year.
If the charitable intent already exists, appreciated stock is worth discussing before someone reaches for the checkbook.
Stop buying more
Every quarter, the company paid Paul a dividend and every quarter he reinvested the dividends automatically.
In Paul's situation, this position did not need any more encouragement. Turning off the dividend reinvestment was an easy way to stop adding fuel to the fire. It also freed up cash he could put toward the rest of his portfolio.
What if the stock keeps going up?
It may.
Diversification does not guarantee the highest return. Paul was not minimizing the position because he believed his former employer was a bad company. He was minimizing it because it made up 45% of his portfolio.
Imagine Paul never owned the stock. Instead, he retires with $2 million sitting in cash.
Would Paul take $900,000 and buy shares of his former company?
That question makes the risk a lot easier to see.
Paul's employer stock had done something incredible.
It helped him build wealth.
He did not need to spend the rest of his retirement asking it to protect that wealth too.
Any client specific information in this article, including names, ages, occupations and financial figures, is fictionalized and used for illustrative purposes only. The examples are not intended to represent any particular client, investment or recommendation. Investment strategies involve risk, and diversification does not guarantee a profit or protect against loss.
Sources
- Internal Revenue Service - https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409 Used to explain: The federal tax treatment of long-term capital gains and the general 0%, 15% and 20% long-term capital gains rate structure.
- Internal Revenue Service - https://www.irs.gov/individuals/net-investment-income-tax Used to explain: The 3.8% Net Investment Income Tax that can apply to certain investment income for taxpayers whose income exceeds the applicable thresholds.
- Internal Revenue Service - https://www.irs.gov/taxtopics/tc409 Used to explain: How capital losses offset capital gains, the annual deduction for excess net capital losses and the carryforward of unused capital losses.