Also sent by email as The Locus Letter on February 28, 2026, titled “💸 Your tax refund might be a red flag”.
Every spring, a funny little ritual plays out across America.
Someone opens their tax return, sees a big refund, and says, “Nice. We beat the IRS.”
I get it. It feels like a win. Like you outsmarted a complicated system and got your money back in one piece.
But most of the time, that is not what happened.
Most of the time, you did not beat the IRS. You just gave them too much money throughout the year and they handed back the extra without interest. Which is a bit like finding $20 in your winter coat, except you put it there yourself. Nice surprise, until you realize you probably could have used it last week. Say, to tip the nice high school kid at Dairy Queen after opening your wallet and realizing there was no cash inside, while your wife gave you the big guilty eyes in front of the staff and the whole line. Not that I am speaking from a weirdly specific personal example or anything…
That does not mean a refund is bad. It does mean it is worth asking a calmer, smarter question.
Was this a victory or was this just an expensive habit wearing a party hat?
The real issue
Most people think a tax refund is a bonus.
In reality, a refund is usually just your money coming back to you. Money you already earned, but did not get to use, save, or invest during the year.
For retirees and near retirees, this happens a lot because income gets “layered.” Social Security. Pension. IRA withdrawals. Part time work. Dividends and capital gains. Maybe a Roth conversion. Each one can have withholding rules that do not talk to each other.
So the real issue is not “refund good” or “refund bad.”
The real issue is control.
Control means you get to choose. Do you want more cash flow each month? Or do you want the IRS to hold extra as a forced savings plan? Either can be fine. What we want to avoid is accidental overpaying, or the opposite problem… an April surprise.
Key terms (plain English)
- Withholding: Taxes taken out of a paycheck, pension, or IRA distribution before the money hits your bank account.
- Estimated tax payments: Taxes you send in during the year when withholding is not happening automatically.
- Safe harbor: A rule that can protect you from underpayment penalties if you pay in “enough” during the year, even if you still owe a bit at filing.
- Underpayment penalty: A fee the IRS can charge if you did not pay enough tax during the year, even if you pay the full balance by April.
- Total tax: The final tax you owed for the year, shown on your tax return, before subtracting what you already paid in.
- Refund: The amount you overpaid. It is not a prize. It is a reconciliation.
The Refund Control System
The framework I use is the Refund Control System.
The goal is simple. Aim for “boring.” Not a giant refund. Not a scary bill. Just a clean landing.
Think of your taxes like a thermostat, not a scoreboard.
A scoreboard tells you who won. A thermostat keeps the house comfortable all year. If the house is freezing in January but perfect in April, the thermostat did not do its job.
A big refund is often the same. It can mean you were “too cold” all year. You paid extra each month, then got comfort later. That is not wrong. It is just a choice. And a lot of people never realize they are making it.
The Refund Control System says: set your withholding so you are close to your actual tax bill during the year, then do one quick midyear check to keep it on track.
Not perfection. Control.
Step-by-step
- Find your “anchor number” in under 2 minutes.Pull up last year’s tax return and locate your total tax. That is the anchor for planning. If you do not have it handy, your tax software, preparer or client portal usually does.
- Identify your “withholding engines.”Make a short list of where taxes can be withheld automatically:
- Wages (if still working)
- Pension payments
- Social Security (optional withholding)
- IRA distributions, including RMDs (you can choose withholding)Then note which ones currently withhold and at what rate.
- Choose the simplest lever first.For many retirees, the cleanest lever is IRA withholding on distributions, including RMDs. Here is why. It is flexible, easy to adjust and can be timed later in the year if needed.If you are still working, your W-4 is often the best lever. If you have a pension, the pension withholding election is a close second.
- Do one midyear “tax weather check.”Pick one date you will repeat every year, like late June or early July.At that check, you are not trying to rebuild your entire tax return. You are asking:Then adjust one lever, not five. A small change now can prevent a big adjustment later.
- Are we on pace to pay enough during the year to avoid penalties?
- Are we drifting toward a huge refund or a surprise bill?
A simple scenario (round numbers)
Let’s use one clean example.
A couple is retired. Their total tax for last year was $20,000. This year, they have withholding coming from a pension and from Social Security. Combined, it is set to $30,000.
When they file, they get a $10,000 refund.
In reality, they paid $10,000 more than they needed to during the year.
If that same $10,000 had stayed in their household month by month, that is about $800 a month of extra breathing room. Or it could have funded travel, home projects, giving or simply a larger cash cushion that reduced stress.
Now flip the situation.
If they were only withholding $10,000 and their total tax still landed at $20,000, they could owe $10,000 at filing. That is where stress shows up, and where safe harbor and underpayment penalties start to matter.
The point is not to chase a perfect zero.
The point is to make the result intentional.
Guardrails (what this does NOT mean)
- This does NOT mean a refund is always “bad.” Some households prefer a refund because it reduces anxiety, especially in the first year of retirement or after a big income change.
- This does NOT mean you should cut withholding aggressively. If you cut too far, you can create a surprise bill and potentially underpayment penalties.
- This does NOT mean safe harbor is something to ignore. It is often the guardrail that lets you adjust calmly, especially if income is lumpy from capital gains, Roth conversions or one time distributions.
Rules of Thumb
- Big refund two years in a row = probably worth checking withholding
- Still working = start with the W-4
- Mostly retired = start with pension or IRA withholding
- Lumpy income = assume a midyear tax check is part of the job
- Owe every April = do not wait until March to fix it
Here is the bottom line
A refund is not a trophy. It is feedback.
If yours is consistently large, you may be giving the IRS an interest free loan. If yours swings wildly, your withholding engines may not be coordinated.
Either way, you can fix it with one small, repeatable system.
Pull up last year’s tax return and write down your total tax, then compare it to how much you had withheld this year so far.
Less stress at filing time and more control over monthly cash flow for the life you are actually living.
You’re not behind. You’re building a repeatable system.