Warren Buffett is often credited with two simple rules:
Rule No. 1: do not lose money.
Rule No. 2: do not forget Rule No. 1.
That line is a little extreme if taken literally, because every investor will experience declines at some point. But the spirit of it matters a lot more once work optionality starts shrinking and withdrawals start getting closer.
Story Time
It started with a Christmas present.
A Peloton bike showed up at his house in December 2020. It was for his wife and she absolutely loved it. So when he looked at the company behind the bike, it did not feel like “a stock.” It felt like something he understood.
Then he did something that made perfect emotional sense.
He bought Peloton ( PTON ) in the middle of the 2020 chaos.
On March 23, 2020, PTON closed at $23.34.
By the time we met in August 2021, it had become life changing money. Our meeting was in mid-August. I remember looking at the chart before our conversation just to sanity-check what I was about to see.
On August 2, 2021, PTON closed at $120.69.
That is roughly a 5x move from those March 2020 prices. And this was not a small sum of money.
He had put a huge portion of his net worth into the stock, inside his rollover IRA. He pulled the statement up on his screen and with a half laugh that was really a little bit of adrenaline, said something like, “This is the one thing I did right during COVID.”
Then came the line I hear a lot, in different versions.
“If I sell and it keeps going up, I’ll feel sick.”
So I tried to slow the conversation down.
I told him, “I am not asking you to predict Peloton. I am asking you to decide how much control one company should have over your retirement.”
I asked one simple question.
“If this got cut in half, would that change your plans?”
He did not answer right away.
Because that is the moment where people realize this is not really about return anymore. It is about what happens to life if the story changes.
What made this hard was that the stock had rewarded him for being bold and the bike in his house made the story feel personal. It is very human to confuse familiarity with safety.
See part two below…
The Real Issue
Diversification is not a performance trick. It is a damage control tool.
Retirement is different from your 30s and 40s. Earlier in life, you still have new savings coming in, more working years ahead and more time for markets to do what markets tend to do eventually. Near retirement, the job changes. The name of the game is no longer doing anything and everything to get extra return. It is protecting the nest egg you already earned from the kind of setback that changes choices at exactly the wrong time.
I have sat across the table from a lot of households where the real risk was not that they were too conservative. It was that they were still playing the accumulation game with retirement money. They were still acting like the goal was to win the race, when the real goal had become finishing with the baton still in hand.
The attached chart captures one of the cleanest truths in investing.
- A 20% loss needs a 25% gain to fully recover.
- A 30% loss needs a 43% gain to fully recover.
- A 50% loss needs a 100% gain to fully recover.
- A 60% loss needs a 150% gain to fully recover.
- A 70% loss needs a 233% gain to fully recover.
That is the kind of math that sounds obvious once you see it and oddly invisible before you do.
There is a second layer people miss. Recovery is not just about the percentage gain required. It is also about time.
Summary of Major Recovery Durations
Here are the big historical stretches where the S&P 500 price index fell from a prior peak and then took more than 5 years to get back above that old high (a “breakeven” in index level, not counting dividends).
- Great Depression era
- Prior peak: August 1929 (pre-Depression record)
- Recovery above prior high: September 1954
- Time to recover: about 25 years
- 1973–74 bear market and stagnation
- Prior peak: 120.24 on January 11, 1973
- Recovery above prior high: 121.44 on July 17, 1980
- Time to recover: about 7.5 years
- Dot-com bust
- Prior peak: 1,527.46 on March 24, 2000
- Recovery above prior high: 1,530.23 on May 30, 2007
- Time to recover: about 7.2 years
- Global Financial Crisis
- Prior peak: 1,565.15 on October 9, 2007
- Recovery above prior high: 1,569.19 on March 28, 2013
- Time to recover: about 5.5 years
Two quick notes (because people often mean different things by “recover”).
Part Two
As for the family with the Peloton…
We did not end up working together as he did not want to take my, not so sexy, advice.
I do not know what he did with the position.
Here is what I do know.
Since then, Peloton’s stock has taken a very different path. As of March 4, 2026, PTON closed at $3.85.
I do not tell this story to pick on Peloton nor the client. After all, hindsight is always 20/20.
I tell this story because it is the cleanest picture of concentration risk I know.
A single winning stock can feel like proof you are smart.
In retirement planning, it can also become a single point of failure.
Guardrails (what this does NOT mean)
- This does not mean stocks are bad, or that retirees should avoid them entirely. It means stock exposure should match the job the money needs to do.
- This does not mean diversification guarantees gains or eliminates losses. The SEC is clear on that point. It is a risk-management tool, not a promise.
- This does not mean every concentrated position must be sold tomorrow morning. Taxes, embedded gains, charitable goals and estate considerations all matter. The right answer is often a process, not a panic move.
Bottom Line
If you are in or nearing retirement, the biggest investing question is often not, “How do I get more return?”
It is, “How do I avoid the kind of loss that forces bad decisions later?”
Diversification will never be the flashy part of a financial plan. But it is often one of the most important.
Action item: See if any specific security makes up more than 5% of your net worth. One oversized position can quietly turn a market event into a family event.
If you have any questions about this article or a similar situation applies to you, reply to this email or shoot me a message. I reply to every email sent my way.
I’m always happy to help!
Sources
- Investor.gov, Diversify Your Investments Learn more here: SEC investor education page explaining diversification in plain English.Used in this article to explain: why diversification reduces concentration risk but does not guarantee against loss.
- SEC, Beginners’ Guide to Asset Allocation, Diversification, and Rebalancing Learn more here: SEC overview of how asset allocation and diversification work together.Used in this article to explain: the core purpose of diversification and the role of portfolio mix.
- FINRA, Asset Allocation and Diversification Learn more here: FINRA investor page on spreading risk across asset classes and rebalancing.Used in this article to explain: concentration risk and retirement portfolio guardrails.
- FRED, S&P 500 Price Index Learn more here: Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis data series for the S&P 500 price index.Used in this article to explain: how long some prior stock market recoveries took after major peaks.